Affordable Insurance Tailored for You

An Ohio-based insurance company offering personalized quotes from multiple carriers for your changing needs.

Your Needs Are One-of-a-Kind

So why choose a one-size-fits-all policy? Your insurance plan should be tailored to meet your specific needs — whether you own a business or have a family — without gaps in coverage or costly, unnecessary add-ons.

Insurance to Protect What Matters Most

At All-Ohio Insurance, we customize every quote for every customer, because every client’s needs are unique. That personal touch combined with access to a broad network of providers ensures that the things that matter most to you are covered at a price you can afford.

How to Apply for Coverage

We make establishing coverage easy — and that starts with the application process.

Contact Us

Reach out via phone, email, or text to tell us you’re interested.

Get a Quote

We’ll provide you with a customized proposal outlining the terms of your coverage.

Approve & Sign

If you’re satisfied with the proposal, you’ll sign paperwork to initiate coverage.

You’re Covered

You’ll receive coverage that’s tailored to you, giving you security and peace of mind.

GET A QUOTE

Over 20 Years of Local Expertise and Personalized Service

The All-Ohio Insurance team has served the insurance needs of families across Ohio for over two decades, previously operating as Shaffer & Associates Insurance. As our agency has grown, we stand firm in our commitment to deliver excellent customer service whenever you need us.

About Us

We’ve Got You Covered

Whether you’re seeking coverage as an individual or a business, our offerings below will keep you protected at a price point that fits your finances.

Personal Insurance Options Include:

Home
Auto
Renters
Life
“Toy” (Motorcycle, RV, Watercraft, etc.)
“Umbrella” Total Asset Protection

View all Personal Insurance Options

Business Insurance Options Include:

Commercial Property
Commercial Auto
Business Liability Coverage
Commercial Umbrella
Builders Risk Insurance
Bonds

View all Business Insurance Options

All-Ohio Insurance is ready to point you in a direction that’s best for you.

GET A QUOTE

“Great place of business! great service and they honestly do everything they can to save you money! 100% satisfied!”

– Nicole
“Great local agency! Took the time to explain the differences in coverage for me. Very helpful, nice staff. Ended up saving me almost $400!”

– Michelle
“Trent helped me get in contact with another driver to cover the damage they did to my car. Trent went above an beyond to help me chase the guy down. His help is Greatly Appreciated!!”

– Heidi
“Knowledgeable and helped me get the coverage I needed for my business.”

– Mike
“Kelly does an amazing job of following up and answering questions. Her dedication to her clients, as well as her excellence in providing personalized customer support, makes a difference in a world that has become mostly personalized.”

– Lisa